Cardiac arrest occurs in both men and women, but women are 27% less likely to receive bystander CPR.1 Hesitation to perform CPR on women is common, especially in public settings. Research shows that bystanders are most concerned about exposing the victim or being accused of sexual assault.2 This article will discuss how to address these concerns. It is important for all genders to receive CPR when in cardiac arrest.
What should I do if a woman is wearing a bra? Should I leave it on?
No. The American Heart Association guidelines state that all clothing should be removed from the chest before performing CPR or applying an Automated External Defibrillator (AED). Clothing can make it hard to find proper hand placement when performing CPR. Hands should be placed in the center of the chest, on the lower half of the breastbone. When a bra is removed breasts will naturally fall to the sides. This applies to breasts of any size and will allow for proper hand placement without needing to touch them.
AED placement is an important part of CPR. One pad is placed on the upper right chest and the other pad is placed on the lower left side of the chest, along the ribs. In the case of a woman with large breasts, it may be necessary to lift the left breast for proper AED pad placement. In this case, it is best to use the back of the hand to lift the breast to place the pad.
Metal, like the underwire in a bra, can potentially interfere with the shock an AED delivers. This means that the AED may not work if a bra is on. This can also apply to metal body jewelry. To be safe, everything metal should be removed from the chest if possible.
I am concerned about exposing someone, what about their privacy?
Cardiac arrest is a life-threatening situation. Cultural sensitivity is important but saving a life is the top priority. After clothing is removed from the chest and AED pads are placed, available cloth can be draped back over the chest to preserve modesty. Protecting privacy can also be done by reminding bystanders to respect the victim. Photos and videos are inappropriate in these situations. Only those helping the victim should be in view of their exposed chest.
What if I am accused of sexual assault?
Protect yourself by acting with good intentions. Most states have good samaritan laws that protect civilians who perform CPR. Remember, exposing the chest is necessary for medical care. Proper hand placement does not involve inappropriate touch. This guidance is agreed upon by medical and legal professionals. Follow your training and do your best to protect victim privacy.
Conclusion
It is important to provide CPR to all victims of cardiac arrest, despite gender. Concerns for privacy and inappropriate behavior are valid but can be addressed. Exposing the chest of a victim with breasts must be done to save their life. Modesty can be preserved as much as possible but should not delay medical care.
References:
- Blewer AL, McGovern SK, Schmicker RH, et al. Gender Disparities Among Adult Recipients of Bystander Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Public. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes. 2018;11(8):e004710. doi:10.1161/CIRCOUTCOMES.118.0047102.
- Becker TK, Gul SS, Cohen SA, et al. Public perception towards bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Emerg Med J. 2019;36(11):660. doi:10.1136/emermed-2018-208234
Very helpful information, a video on this will really help the people who can help others.
How do you take the bra off if you can’t cut no scissors .
Chest compressions can be performed if a bra is still in place. A bra, however, will affect the shock from a defibrillator by potentially diverting the electricity over the skin instead of through the skin if there is an underwire. If you’re unable to cut or remove the bra, it can be pushed down so that it is at least two inches below the AED pad.
Very informative. A video of proper CPR to man and woman will be very useful for all.
Do you need to take a spots bra off?
It is recommended that the chest be clear of clothing and jewelry before use of a defibrillator. This would include the removal of a sports bra or other non-underwire garment.
Thank you so much for your information.most people hesitate to ask this,or they may face this problem suddenly,and don’t know what to do.
I was wondering if it was necessary to remove the bra. In today’s climate, a man cutting the bra of a woman is definitely not without question! It’s great that you tell everyone to put aside their petty social issues and remember it’s solely to save her life! It is far from inappropriate, if done with
the intention of saving a life. Thank you